This is topic 2005: The Review in forum The Library at TMO Talk.


To visit this topic, use this URL:
http://www.themoononline.com/cgi-bin/Forum/ultimatebb.cgi?ubb=get_topic;f=2;t=001699

Posted by Vogon Poetess (Member # 164) on :
 
Well, I know it's not really the end of the year yet, but I thought I could use my time off productively.

Here's where you can recommend ONE fillum, book and album that has rocked your 2005. Then you could do a quick summary of the year, if it's interesting.

Fillum

Cross of Iron epitomises everything that is great about 70s films, war films and Sam Peckinpah films. I mean, it's a film about war, made in the 70s and directed by Sam Peckinpah. Why the fuck haven't you all rushed out and bought it?

Book

You will never read a more tightly plotted and enthralling series of graphic novels than 100 Bullets. I suppose there are lots of people who will never read it. God I hate people.

Album

The CDs that have been on my player most this year have been the superb Gorillaz second album and Gwen Stefani's fun girly nonsense.

2005: a nice fat bonus from work to end the year richly, too many weddings and house moves, zilcho sexing and some locust trauma.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
Okay.

Film

I'm going to cheat here, and instead just say 'Stanley Kubrick'. I realised around the middle of the year that I hadn't seen one Kubrick film so I bought The Shining, Clockwork Orange and 2001 and...OHMYFUCKINGGOD. I can't put into words how stunned I was, both at the brilliance of the visuals and sound, but at my fugging ignorance of this man previously. Dr. Strangelove is on the xmas list.

Book

I've only read the first three 100 Bullets books. Kovacs recommended them to me and they are great.

My favorite book that I read this year is Captain Corellis Mandolin. I was a bit (a lot) wanky and read this in Corfu. I liked it, but hated the ending.

I also read the Magus. I liked the sex bits. Bit of a poor year for Roy and books.

Album

Kate Bush's new one. To be honest, I would listen to an hour of Kate Bush doing her shopping and it would still be my album of the year. There is one song, can't remember it's name, where she sings about a washing machine and it reminds me too much of a Josie Lawrence (?) turn on Who's Line Is It Anyway.

2005: Passed my driving test. Drove a white van about. Posted on the internet. A lot.
 
Posted by Ghost of George (Member # 860) on :
 
Book: "Extremely Loud & Incredibly Close" by Jonathan Safran Foer. It made me sob when nobody was around to hear or see. It also made me smile alot.

Film: Rushmore. I can't believe it's taken me until 2005 to see a film Wes Anderson directed back in 1998. I've now watched it at least 5 times.

Album: I've had a bit of a micro-retro year musically. The best thing about MP3 players is the immediacy they give to music. It's enabled me to listen to a lot of the albums in my collection that I otherwise wouldn't put on the stereo. Sorry I can't name an album, how about a playlist instead? Here's my "Don't kill anyone today" playlist that I need to listen to on the train to prevent myself stabbing strangers.


Pink Floyd "Comfortably Numb"
Jack Johnson "Crying Shame"
The Chillis "Zephyr Song"
Portishead "Numb"
Counting Crows "Perfect Blue Buildings"
Damien Rice "Volcano"
The Cranberries "Zombie"
Embrace "Come Back to What You Know"
Richard and Linda Thompson "I want to see the bright lights tonight"
Jeff Buckley "Hallelujah"
Gorillaz "The Sounder"

If I had to, really had to, pick an album of 2005, it would be Jack Johnson "In Between Dreams".


What have I been doing this year? Being miserable. Getting drunk. Going into hospital. Dying. Joining an internet bulletin board. Hello.
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
Fucking hell, The Cranberries followed by Embrace would send me into an unstoppable killing rage.

Film If... Like others, I'm naming a movie that totally slipped under my radar for my whole life. I fucking loved If.... It's so mad and aggressive and tits. A ferocious, snarling mutt of a film.

Book Godd, it's hard to believe that I discovered 100 Bullets only this year, given that I've spent eight months evangelising about it. I think the best thing without pictures I've picked up this year is Jitterbug Perfume by Tom Robbins.

Music Janis Joplin, man! Another retro one, and I'm sorry. Unfortunately there was no good music released this year. I downloaded the Kaiser Chiefs album the other day, which caused me to wince a bit, ethically speaking. What's the morals on downloading shit albums? On the one hand I'm stealing from the band, but on the other it does spare them from comitting an even grosser ethical injustice by charging me money to listen to this fucking shit. Anyway, it was so horribly recycled, so horribly knowing, at actually made me really genuinely angry that they were so popular at the moment. I wanted to punch everyone who ever championed this awful 'music to stroke your chin to'.

Game Resident Evil 4 on the Gamecube. Such variety! Such imagination! I played this straight after F.E.A.R and it really does show up the PC game for being really really uninspired.

Theatre King Lear. The one at the Alberry. I caught a couple of the Shakepare plays in the RSC season, including Macbeth, but to my suprise I actual much preferred Lear. It had a better swordfight at the end.

2005: Fresh start, really. New homes, new job, new relationship and an unmatched spurt of creativity. A great year, in fact.

[ 06.12.2005, 04:00: Message edited by: Thorn Davis ]
 
Posted by Fionnula the Cooler (Member # 453) on :
 

 
Posted by Black Mask (Member # 185) on :
 
Music
 -
Shitmat - Full English Breakfest

This is disorientatingly noisy, fast, eclectic and daft. The only new album I've enjoyed from beginning to end all year.


Film
 -
Oldboy

I saw this for the first time on DVD, shortly after watching Kill Bill. Poor Quentin... this furious, compelling masterpiece propels and shocks, where its mainstream counterpart arches an eyebrow and bores. Squid!


Books
 -
100 Bullets

Another vote for the Azzarello and Risso masterpiece. What kicked off as an interesting revenge tale has opened out to become a vast and overwhelming conspiracy epic built from the ground up with individual tragedies.

[ 30.11.2005, 06:43: Message edited by: Black Mask ]
 
Posted by dang65 (Member # 102) on :
 
Film

Well, it wouldn't be the latest Harry Potter or Wallace & Grommit, which is all I've seen this year at the pictures. Both great visually of course, but I think that's pretty much a given with movies these days, just way too incomplete in the case of HP and way too dragged out in the case of W&G. But this is supposed to be a positive thread isn't it?

Probably the freshest in my mind is Gangs of New York, because I watched it last night for the first time. Trouble is, it was dubbed into French and I missed the very beginning which Leonardo keeps flashing back to all the way through and I didn't know why. So, what I ended up with was really like travelling back in time and just watching life in an olden days city without knowing who anyone was or what they were doing. You know, like if you sit and watch life go by in a foreign city now, with people shouting incoherent giberish at each other. Well, it was like that but back in the past. It was very atmospheric. I'm loathe to watch the film in English now in case it's shite, because it did look good. It also ties in loosely with...

Book

I've read a lot of biographies of comedians and musicians this year, and I've no idea why because they always disappoint me, except when they're fantastically embellished (er, made up) like No One Here Gets Out Alive or The Hammer Of The Gods. I quite enjoyed Billy by Pamela Stephenson, but not so much that I'd suggest anyone buy it, unless it's in a charity shop like my copy was.

What I am enjoying is a book called Black Ivory, about the history of the British Slave Trade. It's one of those history books where the writer just wanders off in any direction he fancies. There's no particular chronology or organisation to it. He spends quite a long time going on about the coffee shops of Olde London, which contrasted nicely with the recent survey about Nowadays coffee shops - how they used to be the centre of business and trade and advanced thinking and politics, and now... they aren't. Unless you include the latest Bob Dylan CD in Starbucks. And that kind of tied in with Gangs Of New York, where the whole community used to get together in those big bars and sort out all their business. Maybe some people still do that now.

Music

And another connection... I've listened to a lot of stuff this year, but I think the most unusual would be that I've found I'm madly in love with Sinead O'Connor! ...'s voice, I mean. She turns up as a guest singer on loads of records I've got at home - Jah Wobble, Asian Dub Foundation, Natacha Atlas, Massive Attack... all that shit I listen to a lot - and she always makes just the right contribution. Cracking voice.

I was sent a copy of her traditional Irish songs album from a couple of years ago, and that includes Paddy's Lament... which is about Irish emigrants landing in America and getting drafted straight into the Civil War. Great song, and superb version by Sinead. Bob Marley's Buffalo Soldier tells a similar story from the Caribbean point of view of course... more connections, look...

I just bought Sinead's new album, which is her covers of various reggae protest/religious tunes. Not as heavy musically as some of those collaborations, but who else that's white could have the nerve to do those songs and still get away with it?

So, there's yet another totally undervalued singer IMHO, and don't anyone compare her with The Cranberries, I beg of yers.
 
Posted by George the Robot (Member # 681) on :
 
Film
Like Mask, I'm going to have to go for Oldboy. Watched during the most depressing week of my year - off work with horrible debilitating sweaty feverish flu type thing, and surrounded by the grey menace that is Croydon. Oldboy is a masterpiece, combining gut-wrenching horror, kung-fu, black comedy, revenge, gob-smacking plot twists and an amazing inner beauty that made me feel as happy as I did all week.

Book
I loved The Big Nowhere by James Ellroy. Thorn has waxed lyrical about this on here before in much more detail than I have the time or the talent to attempt. Put simply, this is a juggernaut of a crime novel. Big, sweeping plot, powerful language and enough twists to leave you begging for mercy.

Album
Whilst on holiday I particularly enjoyed the sunny Buena Vista Social Club which was on my mate's IPod, and has since been added to the the Robot collection. My other best purchase of the year was The Man Comes Around by Johnny Cash, which is rarely far from my CD player.

My year: Job depression, marital bliss and improved living conditions.

[ 30.11.2005, 08:41: Message edited by: George the Robot ]
 
Posted by dance margarita (Member # 848) on :
 
film: i have just tried to find a definitive list of the films released this year, because i have been to the kino a fucking fuckload in 2005. nothing's really standing out in my memory but oldboy- during which i had one of those utterly beautiful transcendant moments of feeling utterly alone in your experience of a film despite being ina room full of similarly gripped people, do you know what i mean?- and a film i watched about the feminist presence at the 1972 democratic convention. i enjoyed the edukators; how much of that was because of the almost excessive dreaminess of daniel bruehl, i am actually incapable of telling you. the edukators was also released in 2004. you know, i watch a lot of cinema in rep.

book: well done mr bukowski! noone has ever won this prize two years in a row! last year ham on rye, this year women. what would you like for your prize? a... a... blowjob? no, mr bukowski, i dont think so. you might be a genius, but you look like a gorg! also. you are dead. sorry.

theatre: i only went to the theatre twice this year, both within two days of each other. both were ace, but tristan and yseult kicked my hinder so hard i had the bruises three weeks later. my best thing this year: becoming a lady who matinees. be it the theatre or the cinema, there is something just so fucking lush about partaking in The Arts on your own, in the afternoon, with a paperbag of satsumas, a chocolate bar and a smoothie and no- one to report to.

music: no albums grabbed me this year. smile has inserted itself into my life as a given, whether im dabbing eyeshadow onto my eyelids ineptly all over my eyesockets before trolling to work on a friday, or tapping like a drunken stick insect on my canon starwriter at 2 am after 4 pints of cheap lager, the chances are ill be listening to smile. or all the new mistakes by bucky. or ...michigan... by sufjan stevens. i went to lots of concerts. my top 3: the rogers sisters (keywords: intense bassist; guitarist; nice hair; tourbus over- enthusuastic response embarrassment) at louisiana, kimya dawson in cardiff (keywords: off her mash on sudafed; libellous machael jackson jesus juice story), and lcd soundsystem on valentines day (i danced more ecstatically than i ever have whilst 100% sober). this year i have mostly been reembracing my inner indie kid, which has been fucking weird and fucking nice.

television: still havent seen more than 2 episodes of the last season of 6fu (looks with slitted eyes and pursed lips at boy racer). but that documentary about taxidermists was fucking spot on. actually, the documentary about the naked ramblers last night was a proper gem too.

my year: not unusually, 2005 has been a combination of absolutely knee- chewing depression and hello- trees- hello- skies- its- all- so- beautiful!£!". but i moved house, i have found an excellent banana cake recipe, am learning how to knit, am almost debt- free, and i adore where i live. plus, i have lots of afternoons free to go and sit in dark rooms eating satsumas on my own. its alright, this adulthood lark.
 
Posted by MiscellaneousFiles (Member # 60) on :
 
Film:
 -

Music:
 -

Book:
 -

Game:
 -

[Wink]
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
Your film image didn't open for me, misc. What was it?
 
Posted by MiscellaneousFiles (Member # 60) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
Your film image didn't open for me, misc. What was it?

Batman Begins.
 
Posted by squeegy (Member # 136) on :
 
Film
The two movies that really stuck out for me this year were A Clockwork Orange and Apocalypse Now. Not exactly cutting edge but I did buy them on DVD this year so they count.

Book
As I have said before, I really enjoyed reading 1984. Like really, really, couldn't stop turning the (virtual) pages. In fact it was the first book I had read as an "eBook" and to be honest I don't think I could have finished reading many books on a screen. So yeah, it must have been good.

I also read the whole Harry Potter saga through again. Mainly because I couldn't remember what happened but also because I am a cheap (poor) bastard and didn't want to buy (couldn't afford) more books. I really enjoyed them too. Much more than I thought I would. Which was nice.

Album
Hmmmm. There hasn't been anything new which I have really super enjoyed but I have liked A Crow Left of the Murder by Incubus. I think this is their new album but I may be wrong. I have also listened to OK Computer for the first time (for shame!!) and then decided to listen to it again. And again. And again and again and again...

So 2005. It started off as just about the worst year ever. No job, no money, no friends, no life. It could only get better. And did! I even have a possible promotion in the pipeline. Which is a surprise concidering it has mostly involved TMO and Urban Dead.
 
Posted by Boy Racer (Member # 498) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by dance margarita:
television: still havent seen more than 2 episodes of the last season of 6fu (looks with slitted eyes and pursed lips at boy racer)

And with an attitude like that you're not likely to, are you Ms Pracatan?
Also you saw Oldboy last year.

I will need some further time to cogitate, Grossman style, on my own responses to this thread.
 
Posted by saltrock (Member # 622) on :
 
FILM I don't watch a lot of films and when I do get to go the cinema it tends to be to watch children's films with Ellie. I did however, muchly enjoy watching The House of Flying Daggers the other night when I was in my hotel room in Glasgow, pissed as a handcart.

For childrens' films, I think Nanny McPhee has been the best of the bunch, closely followed by W&G.

BOOK I've gone through a terrible lightweight phase this year where I have read practically nothing worthy at all and immersed myself in a load of chicklit and aga-sagas "because they are easy" and I can sort of switch off and lose myself in them without having to engage my brain. I did recommend Ghostwritten, which I still love, and I, Lucifer though. Also, I have got 1984 out of the library and am going to read it as everyone seems to think it is totally worth it.

MUSIC It's been the year of the chillout in our house. Zero7, Lamb, Air, Pink Floyd [thank you someone on here who said I should listen to them ages ago]. Also been listening to the Gorillaz, Paul Weller and of course the God that is Bruce Springsteen. Nothing really new that has caught my attention. All the Killers/Kaiser Chiefs/whatevs all sound pretty much the same to me to be honest. I do quite like the Black Eyed Peas cd for in the car though with Ellie. [And I really do love X&Y by Coldplay!]

MY YEAR Started not so bad, steadily got duller and duller and duller. Company going through a merger at the moment so have been fraught for the last couple of months and far too busy. Ellie starting to realise that she has a personality and a LOT of attitude - seems to be a budding teenager at the age of 7. Dave is living in two different homes and comes home ocassionally to eat and sleep [the cat]. My brother has been diagnosed HIV+.

I'm hoping next year is calmer.

[ 30.11.2005, 11:47: Message edited by: saltrock ]
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
I'm sorry to hear that saltrock.
 
Posted by dang65 (Member # 102) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by saltrock:
Also, I have got 1984 out of the library and am going to read it as everyone seems to think it is totally worth it.

I can't believe there are adults here that haven't read/hadn't read till recently 1984. When I was a child it was considered such a brilliant description of the perils of a totalitarian government and the unacceptable horror of the withdrawal of freedom and humanity that we were made to read it. Anyone that refused was beaten and then made to stand in their underpants in the school yard in the middle of November.
 
Posted by Black Mask (Member # 185) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Thorn Davis:
I'm sorry to hear that saltrock.

What? That she really likes Coldplay?
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
That Dave comes home occasionally to eat the cat.

[ 30.11.2005, 12:25: Message edited by: Thorn Davis ]
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
Oh my fucking God.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
What, ralph, what?

What has made you take the Lord's name in vain? What has pulled such surprise from your fingers onto your keyboard and onto my screen?

Tell me, ralph. Tell us all.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
Don't play dumb with me, Roy. You know exactly what I'm outraged at.
 
Posted by Dr. Benway (Member # 20) on :
 
Culturally, quite a bad year.

Film

It's a toss up, I'm afraid [Frown] . Confessions of a Trickbaby, The Descent, and The Shape Of Things have all worked their magic in 2005, but the winner is probably The Shape Of Things. It's a film by Neil Labute from 2003 that muses on the boundaries of art in a jaw droppingly sadistic manner. Out of all the films I've watched, this is the one that fucked me up the most, and left me with sweaty palms and a slightly sick feeling. It could be because I'm notoriously dim that it hurt me so much. More astute viewers would probably be able to second guess it enough to not be wiped out by the events that unfold. Can't really say too much about it, but it's the one that I'll remember from the year.

*****

Unfortunately, Mr. LaBute couldn't be with us tonight, as he's busy fucking theatre groupies up against minimalist backdrops, but he would like to thank me for the props, and for keeping it real - thanks Neil!


Book

The Kid Stays In The Picture. Bear in mind that this riotous autobiographical romp through the golden years of Hollywood has fought off stiff competition from (among others) Brett Easton Ellis, Haruki Murakami, Paul Auster and Gogol, all of whom provided excellent material. The Kid takes home the prize because it was the only one that I would read on the tube and then carry on reading once I got home. Also, a man saw me reading it and said "Hey - that's a great book isn't it!", and I said "yeah", but the point of the story is that the book not only entertained me, but also worked towards helping me to make new friends. Anybody who has ever enjoyed a motion picture would probably find something here.


Album

Scchyeah! I don't really do albums any more. I'm part of the ipod generation who just skips about listening to individual tracks - but I don't even have an ipod! It's not ironic, but you know what I mean. Anyway, contenders this year are the one by The Killers, The Mylo one, and the one by Evil Nine. Mylo gets it, because that's the one that's given me the most raw pleasure. Yes, it's cheesy and popular and advert music, but it always works. It's still got legs, long after the others have been shot in the head for failing to keep up, like in that Richard Bachmann story.

Game

A good year for gaming. Games have been my main love this year, with Half Life 2, GTA San Andreas, F.E.A.R, Fahrenheit, and Resident Evil 4 all weighing in for the title. Some mega budget offerings finally made their way onto my D: drive, and I was pwned by them all. But the suprise winner is rank outsider Darwinia, for being the only game I've played in years that I could genuinely describe a beautiful. It reminded me of the real love that I had for computer games as kid, because it exists without any reference to reality. Set within a computer, the game plays out like a 3D Cannon Fodder, as imagined on a wireframe computer demo from Tomorrow's World circa 1983. There's a sad ambience to the sparse landscapes, and somehow all the cyberpunk notions of alienation are brought to a tear jerking reality as you battle to save your sentient AI worshippers from the jaws of a lethal virus. It's not exactly metaphysical, but birth, struggle and death seem more real in this game than any I've ever played. Also, the soundtrack by Tresk is truly, truly perfect for the game... It goes head to head with Ice Cube on the stereo of my drop top as I bounce through the streets of San Andreas, but wins out because it's an original score, and it's free. Coming over Steam soon, folks!

 -

ETA: My Year: Not bad. A year of aging. Could have partied harder.

[ 30.11.2005, 13:18: Message edited by: Dr. Benway ]
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by ralph:
Don't play dumb with me, Roy. You know exactly what I'm outraged at.

I don't.

But it's good to see Benway back.

[ 30.11.2005, 13:23: Message edited by: Roy ]
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
Oh, Roy. All of TMO has figured it out by now. They're all laughing at you, Roy. Laughing at you. Poor Roy.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
You started it, blaspheming all over the place like a satan-worshipper.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
You started it, blaspheming all over the place like a satan-worshipper.

Like a satan-worshipper? I am a satan-worshipper, Roy. Love him like a brother. I don't believe in your God, Roy.

ETA: You're not Catholic, are you Roy?

[ 30.11.2005, 13:35: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by kovacs (Member # 28) on :
 
I have encountered a great deal of popular culture this year, in terms of music, comics, books (books and comics aren't the same things, gang! it is thicko to pretend 100 Bullets can be your best book of the year!) and cinema. My great moment in 2005 theatre gets its nom by default, simply because I hardly ever go, and it's Nicely-Nicely Johnson with the whole of 1930s New York doing a gospel ensemble of "Siddown You're Rocking the Boat" in Guys and Dolls.

My other choices are based on the fact that they've infected and enriched my life over a period of time -- "texts" that have had at least a medium-term effect on my cultural experience of 2005, rather than being wham-bam-flash-in-the-pans that were great at that moment but forgotten soon afterwards.

music

 -

Arcade Fire, Funeral

I have ex-forumite "Bailey" to thank for this. I squinted at her mails where she claimed Arcade Fire were "teh sexx" but this album's sound crept into me and grew like sad moss. Once I listened to it for a whole afternoon while gradually getting drunk, and it's almost too melancholy to listen to it again now, because that was early summer and now it's so fucking miserably cold.

book

 -


Penguin 70s.

I was scorned for spending £1.50 on each of these well-designed pamphlets, but now I own 32 and they make up a lovely spectrum of colour on my bookshelf, their spines shading from blue to orange. I've also read a lot of samplers from authors I wouldn't otherwise have touched -- Homer, Primo Levi, Wodehouse, James Kelman, Borges, Steinbeck, Hunter S. Thompson -- and have already made avenues towards those writers' longer works. For two months, I was sucked into a small, short-lived literary world for my hours' train journey to work, and another on the return.

comic

 -

Seven Soldiers,
Grant Morrison

God knows how long this saga's been running now... since January? longer than I've had my new job, longer than I've been married. Four monthly issues for each of seven unlikely heroes: an armored cop, a spellaholic witch, a woman encased in bulletskin, a fey blue boy... they're meant to come together as the Seven Soldiers of Victory, our last defence against a harrowing historical enemy called the Sheeda, and so far none of them have even met yet.
Most episodes have been underwhelming; maybe even the concept is hokey beyond redemption. But I've stayed loyal to this dumb comic and its author for months now, so it's formed a constant backdrop to my year.

film

 -

Joss Whedon, Serenity

Maybe it's not the next Star Wars by any stretch, but it almost felt that way at the time, and for a couple of weeks afterwards I was immersed in the mythos through the prequel TV show Firefly, so it felt like more than just a film. At any rate, the best space opera for years, and a joyful experience.

game

 -

GTA San Andreas

Goes without saying I think. This game almost became a second, substitute life for me, for a while... a set of characters more important to me than anything from TV or in films; places that came to feel like a kind of home; memories that rank alongside real ones. I remember San Andreas as vividly as a vacation.

2005

I'm pretty pessimistic about most of my life, past and future, and this year was no exception: apart from my wedding day, which was so perfect I have dreams about it.

[ 30.11.2005, 13:43: Message edited by: kovacs ]
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by ralph:
ETA: You're not Catholic, are you Roy?

I tried, but I wasn't guilty enough.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
quote:
Originally posted by ralph:
ETA: You're not Catholic, are you Roy?

I tried, but I wasn't guilty enough.
So what God were you referring to me blaspheming? Who is your God, Roy?
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
God. You know, Him.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
God. You know, Him.

Oh, God. Sure. Older chap. Long white hair and beard. Fire and brimstone and such.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
That's him. The one you blasphemed against.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
That's him. The one you blasphemed against.

Then why haven't I been struck by lightening yet? Or lost the use of my eyes? I'm not covered in boils yet, Roy. When can I expect the boils?
 
Posted by Kira (Member # 826) on :
 
Fillum

For me I am also a Batman Begins fan, though I also enjoyed Night Watch so I may be on shaky ground...Could I also make a mention of the BBC Taming of The Shrew - a TV film but I liked that a lot...

Book

Most definately 'Glue' by Irvine Welsh which I absolutely loved and was sad when it ended. Reawakened a forgotten passion for Welshs writing.

Album

As top of my playlist on my last.fm account I guess its Jack Johnson.

Also rated Pendulum and Dead Silence Syndicate

2005: New year, New home, new beginnings and going good so far

[ 30.11.2005, 14:26: Message edited by: Kira ]
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
He's forgiven you.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
He's forgiven you.

That reminds me of a humorous story. When I was a child, I wanted nothing more for Christmas than a shiny new red bicycle. I prayed to God each and every night for one. I figured it was in the bag. Chiristmas day comes, and no new bicycle. I was so upset. Then the light shone down upon me. It was all so clear. That night, I went out an stole a shiny new red bicycle from someone in the neighborhood, went home, and prayed for forgiveness.

I don't do God, Roy. Keep your God to yourself, GodBoy.

[ 30.11.2005, 14:31: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
Do you think it's conversations like this one that have given us the reputation of being lame, Roy?

Roy?

[ 30.11.2005, 14:42: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by Physic (Member # 195) on :
 
Film
Joint Security Area, or JSA at it's often referred to, directed by Chan Wook Park, and like all of Park's films utterly engrossing. The film is set during the Korean War, an concerns two guardhouses, either side of a bridge which forms a border crossing between North and South Korea. Park prortrays the friendship which develops between the guards in the two guardhouses, and the dawning realisation that they have more in common with each other than with many of their own comrades. I can't describe adequately how brilliant this film is.

Book
The Hitchhikers Guide To The galaxy, the 4 books in one volume version, cheating a bit I know, but I read this through from start to finish earlier this year and it really is one of the best books I've ever read.

Album
One pretty much none of you will have heard of, 'Are You dead yet?' by the Children Of Bodom, black-metallers extraordinare, I love this album so much it's barely left my CD player since I bought it.

My Year
Not bad at all, I've started playing more sports and thus got myself into slightly better shape, I've had more brilliant nights out than anyone has a right to, been to the Oktoberfest and had a brilliant time, and most recently had quite possibly the most enjoyable weekend away yet, enjoying the company of some utterly lovely friends and consuming untold quantities of beer.
 
Posted by kovacs (Member # 28) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by ralph:
Do you think it's conversations like this one that have given us the reputation of being lame, Roy?

Roy?

What's bafflingly and tediously missing from your "schtick" is any fucking remnant of a joke. Could you please write some material or get some inspiration before wiping your arse on this forum again. It is not a bib for your dribble.
 
Posted by Black Mask (Member # 185) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by kovacs:
books and comics aren't the same things, gang!

Comics are better than books. Plus, hairsplitting, I know... but, you nominated essays, chapters, stories, those aren't the same things as books, are they?

I just read the first issue of the Morrison 7 Soldiers Frankenstein story. I liked it.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by kovacs:
It is not a bib for your dribble.

My mistake. It's obviously a bib for your dribble. [Smile]

[ 30.11.2005, 14:54: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by kovacs:
What's bafflingly and tediously missing from your "schtick" is any fucking remnant of a joke. Could you please write some material or get some inspiration before wiping your arse on this forum again. It is not a bib for your dribble.

I hope that this is aimed at me as well, because it's unfair that ralph gets all the blame for our babble.

Anyway, you are right. I'm going to shut up now. Apols Vogon. This is a good thread.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
I hope that this is aimed at me as well, because it's unfair that ralph gets all the blame for our babble.

Way to stand up and take it like a man, Roy. Well done.

kovacs has a valid point of course. You and I have a tendency to drift off a few times a week, not really contributing much to the boards, even if we do find our conversations amusing. Tell you what kovacs, I'll give this thread some consideration during my ride into the office tomorrow morning, and actually make an attempt at composing a half decent reply. But be forewarned -- if I decide to recap my own 2005 events, prepare to weep. I've had a most unfortunate year.

[ 30.11.2005, 15:02: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by vikram (Member # 98) on :
 
films
best: turtles can fly
worst: a hole in my heart
most enjoyable: mr. & mrs. smith

books
best: two rereads: a perfect spy and running with scissors
worst: girl with a pearl earring
most enjoyable: freakonomics

[ 30.11.2005, 20:13: Message edited by: vikram ]
 
Posted by Samuelnorton (Member # 48) on :
 
Spielfilm

Without a doubt, Der Untergang - probably the most honest retelling of this all too often repeated tale. It wasn't so much the Hitler character for me, but the peripheral players - in particular the Waffen-SS Brigadeführer Wilhelm Mohnke, on whom I wrote a series of papers in the late 1990s. I am sure the directors found some of my scribblings on him somewhere; it was probably the most accurate portrayal of a man who was nothing more than an honest soldier - sarky comments by the likes of David Cesarani notwithstanding.

Outside of my 'study field' the best cinemeatic offering this year had to be Serenity. I had been persuaded to go by Mrs N, who is a fan of Joss Whedon - and I was most impressed. It proved that a decent, well-written story is worth a lot more than assembling an array of household million-dollar names.

Boke

As usual I went through about a dozen works of non-fiction; it's pretty hard to pick a winner but the podium places went to Winifred Wagner: A Life at the Heart of Hitler's Bayreuth by Brigitte Hamann; The State of Africa: A History of Fifty Years of Independence by Martin Meredith and Stasiland by Anna Funder, an excellently-written work that I got as part of a '3 for £10' deal.

Music

Much of the stuff I like is, erm, old - and there was nothing particularly notable this year. Most played CD in the car was probably one of Wagner's Siegfried (highlights), Dido's Life for Rent or disc one from the two-disc The Very Best of Elvis Costello.

Game

I don't play games any more. Unless you count my occasion digging out of Red Alert or Silent Hunter II. Or Monopoly, on a traditional board.
 
Posted by vikram (Member # 98) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Samuelnorton:
Stasiland by Anna Funder

I forgot about this book. Yeah, it's excellent. The cover is really stupid though.
 
Posted by omikin (Member # 37) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Samuelnorton:
Dido's Life for Rent

o the humanity
 
Posted by Endemic (Member # 821) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Samuelnorton:
Without a doubt, Der Untergang

I concur, actually. I saw this last week and it's hauntingly good. The increasing sense of claustrophobia and hysteria is conveyed beautifully. The filming feels dispassionate, almost documentary-style but it does draw you in and leads you to the entirely queasy position of sympathy and empathy for Hitler and Goebbels. Brilliantly acted and with just enough of the horrific about it. I watched in tandem with reading Anthony Beevor's rather excellent Berlin, which helped, lots. Honourable mention on the film front to Goodbye Lenin, a completely different kettle of cod. Hilarious and unique and an excellent antidote and accompaniment to Downfall.

Book
I've been quite disappointed this year with the alleged heavyweights. I waityed in breath baited anticipation for Ian McEwan's Saturday, which needed a good editor and read more like an experiment in form than a novel. Sebastian Faulk's Human Traces has some of his usually excellent prose but was a struggle. Not disappointing, though, was Lunar Park, Breat Easton Ellis' return to form and a cracking horror story with lashings of extra satire thrown in. Currently enjoying China Mieville's short stories.

Music
Not sure if it's this year but I was recently introduced to the Editors and have developed an addiction to The Back Room. It's gorgeous. Fall is a perfect winter track, all sort of maudlin and soaring simultaneously. I love this line: "These dark pubs, we drink in somehow light up when I'm with you." Honourable mention: the already Kovacs mentioned Arcade Fire. Like a melancholy Pixies with strings.

Comics
Having done a screeching U-Turn from my previous indefensible comics are for rubbish people position, thanks in part to certain TMOers, I started reading this stuff only this year. Favourite favourite favourite is Transmetropolitan which kept me utterly engrossed, made me laugh out loud like a loon on the train and gave me Spider Jerusalem to fall in love with. I am considering putting 100 Bullets on my Christmas list.

Games
I don't *do* games but I'm horribly tempted to see if World of Warcraft can kill me where drugs and fags and alcohol have failed. I think that would be funny.
 
Posted by H1ppychick (Member # 529) on :
 
Downfall is on the television next week, fact fans. It's on More4 on Monday night at 9pm.

[ 01.12.2005, 06:17: Message edited by: H1ppychick ]
 
Posted by ben (Member # 13) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by omikin:
o the humanity

What, you're surprised that a neo-nazi's into Dido?
 
Posted by Benny the Ball (Member # 694) on :
 
FIlm - Serinity was pure joy, I ennoyed it enough to get the series out soon after.

Book - The second book in the Historic Illuminatus Chronicles, by Robert Anton Wilson, is one of the best books I have ever read - it is such a shame that the first book is just okay and the third is one of the biggest let downs, making me reluctant to recommend. I'm really enjoying Sven Hassel's first book a lot.

Music - Goldfrapp's new album.

Comics - the fun of the DC comics Infintity Crisis has been enjoyable so far - plus the X-Men collected black and white books 5 and 6 have been excellent.

Games - Urban Dead is about the only game I've played. I tried out Football Manager 2006 demo, but that only lasted for half a season, and my team in 2005 are just too good.
 
Posted by herbs (Member # 101) on :
 
Fillum
Another (shaky parkinsons-style) thumbs up. In fact one of the few films I saw at the cinema this year (Walthamstow doesn't have a cinema! Can you believe it!), it was a masterpiece of claustrophobia and tension. I hope it was nervous tension that made the man behind me bark with laughter when Frau Goebbels slumped on the floor having just poisoned her kinder. Even though you knew the end, it was a white-knuckle number. Unlike Titanic.

Book
Shamefully few books read this year. Everything Is Illuminated was v good, though read over such a long period of time I got a bit lost. Also enjoyed Pussy: For cat who should know better, the unusual phenomenon of a novelty Christmas book that is actually funny.

Album
I listen to less and less music these days, though this year have enjoyed Anthony and his Johnson, Arcade Fire, and, shamefully, Keane.

ETA: Games
Recently reloaded Sim City on to mac. Still rules. Any other gaming opportunities would cause my life to entirely grind to a halt, and my RSI to cripple me. Though I do pay the odd visit to gamehouse.

Year in brief
Domestic sitch on the up - new house, intention for family; professional sitch on the slide - menial tasks for idiots.

[ 01.12.2005, 06:58: Message edited by: herbs ]
 
Posted by Boy Racer (Member # 498) on :
 
Film: History of Violence

 -

I can’t compete with Thorn’s spoiler-free review from the time of it’s release, but suffice to say that like Oldboy last year, History of Violence is a master class in intelligent adult entertainment.
Compelling, woozily bizarre, pitch-black funny, and beautifully acted (particularly by Viggo, Ed Harris, and William Hurt) and directed.
Brilliant from the off-kilter foreboding of it's opening to the tantalisingly clipped end.
Classic Cronenberg, in other words.
Note: Honorable mention to Joss Whedon for managing to get a film of the brilliant Firefly “‘verse” made in the form of Serenity, and for having the balls to challenge his existing fan base whilst attempting to expand it.

TV: The Wire

 -

This amazing HBO series continued to amaze with it’s second series, which I’d argue could now compete with the best of The Sopranos. The only major problem with it being that I suspect I’m the only person in this country except Jim Shelley who’s actually seen any of it.
Note: Honorable mention for another HBO show that no one else has seen, Deadwood, particularly for having Lovejoy losing the plot and bonding with a severed head, Alfredo Garcia style. And finally to Firefly, which I got on DVD, and which features one of the most compelling, funny, and lovingly realised set of characters and universes I’ve ever seen in a show, Sci-fi or not.

LP Record: Demon Days – Gorillaz

 -

Whilst mining a similar vein to their eponymous first album the scope of the music here has been expanded as much as the cast of performers. Richer, darker, and funkier than it’s predecessor.
Note:Honorable mentions go to Supernature – Goldfrapp, Dimanche a Bamako - Amadou & Mariam, Ruby Blue - Róisín Murphy, Dangerdoom - Dangermouse & MF Doom, Funeral - Arcade Fire, and Leaders of the Free World - Elbow.

Gig: Super Furry Animals, Brixton Academy
A blindingly good show by one of the most tragically underappreciated bands of recent times. The Furries are a startling good live band with a scarily expansive back catalogue of fantastic songs, a fantastically bizarre presence on stage, and breathtaking light show. It’s rare that I have left a gig so completely satisfied by the experience.

Book: Beyond Black – Hilary Mantel
Part bleakly comic dissection of contemporary Britain, part truly creepy ghost story, Mantel combines both in this, along with some wicked prose, to produce a truly compelling novel.
Note: 100 Bullets is on the Christmas list.

Video Game: Oddworld – Stranger’s Wrath (Xbox)

 -

The first Abe-free Oddworld game brilliantly and beautifully welded spaghetti-western and first person shooter elements onto the fantastically creative Oddworld universe. A game in two parts, the first a bounty hunter western, the second an all out war game, this was witty, entertaining, addictive, and about the prettiest Xbox game I’ve yet seen. My only quibble would be that it was over too soon.
Note: I probably still played San Andreas most this year, clocking story mode for a second time and picking off yet more of the sub missions. I haven’t played Resident Evil 4 yet, can I borrow it, Thorn/Benway?

Exhibition: Frida Kahlo - Tate Modern

 -

Although I knew I liked Kahlo’s work I wasn’t really expecting the impact that this had on me. I was surprised by how small the majority of her work was, by how poorly the reproductions I had seen reproduced the colours of her originals, and by the sheer intensity of her gaze from the self-portraits.
I left feeling alive in a way I haven’t felt on leaving an exhibition since first seeing Goya’s Black Paintings in Madrid.


As for the year as a whole, I’ll tell you when it’s over.

[ 01.12.2005, 08:25: Message edited by: Boy Racer ]
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Boy Racer:
I haven’t played Resident Evil 4 yet, can I borrow it, Thorn?

No.

So, anyway. I was going to post a 'gig of the year', but I've only been to a measley two gigs this year, making it the most barren year for live music since I started going to gigs in 1994 (Pop Will Eat Itself at the Portsmouth Guildhall, as you ask). Two gigs in a year! Rubbish. Time was I'd go to that many gigs than that in one night.

Still they were both great - the PWEI reunion, and a Ginger acoustic gig at the Barfly in Camden. Clear winner, though, is Pop Will Eat Itself which was just unstoppable, like a runaway freight train. Alongside the Slayer/ Slipknot double bill last year it made me realise how much I really loved going to gigs, a fact I celebrated by not going to any more.
 
Posted by Octavia (Member # 398) on :
 
Film
Cinematically, a close tie between Batman Begins, Mr & Mrs Smith and History of Violence. On the one hand a tightly-plotted, beautifully shot, high-class action movie populated almost exclusively with British actors, on the other hand a romantic comedy with guns (and Angelina Jolie kicking ass wearing nothing but a shirt and wellies), and on the third hand, an unbelievably intelligent analysis of human integrity.

DVD-wise, Miller's Crossing stood out for goodness, and Intolerable Cruelty for comedy. Also reluctantly coming to the conclusion that I do actually sort of like The Big Lebowski. A bit.

Book
Have read mostly college-ordained books this year, but apart from that re-read all the Iain M Banks books in a two week period. They really are quite good.

Music
Discovering Tommy on vinyl. Man alive they knew how to make music forty years ago.

Bar
QI in the QI building. Dark red walls, intelligently chatty staff, bartenders straight out of the forties school of glamour-drinking who mix stunning cocktails without ever measuring any of the ingredients.

Year
A gode one. New house, new job, new qualification, new friends, new stuff-that-isn't-work. Less mountains, though.

[ 01.12.2005, 08:26: Message edited by: Octavia ]
 
Posted by Boy Racer (Member # 498) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Thorn Davis:
quote:
Originally posted by Boy Racer:
I haven’t played Resident Evil 4 yet, can I borrow it, Thorn?

No.
Man that's cold. Is that because you still play it or are you just being a mean spirited bastard, or maybe both?

ETA: Was Poppies really this year? Somehow it seems much longer. Brilliant gig though.

[ 01.12.2005, 08:13: Message edited by: Boy Racer ]
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Boy Racer:
Man that's cold. Is that because you still play it or are you just being a mean spirited bastard, or maybe both?

I haven't finished it yet, plus it's at Octavia's place in Oxford where I can play it and avoid having to talk to her. But I thought it was funnier to say 'No' without explanation.
 
Posted by kovacs (Member # 28) on :
 
It's a fun challenge to scroll up the page from the last post, and guess who chose what before you reach their name.

For instance, I correctly identified Boy Racer based on this line:

quote:
Originally posted by Boy Racer:
Richer, darker, and funkier than it’s predecessor.

After learning that the two extremes of beauty and beastliness, VP and SN, both admired 100 Bullets (or maybe I read wrong... but what I just said was funny anyway lol), I began reading it (a chapter about prisoners) in Waterstones at lunchtime. And returned to work 10 minutes later than I planned! So I revise my opinion -- it could be called a "book with pictures", even a "fat comic" -- and may have to buy another couple of volumes myself. Thanks tmo.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by kovacs:
...it could be called a "book with pictures", even a "phat comic" -- and may have to buy another couple of volumes myself. Thanks tmo.

Man, you've been playing GTA: San Andreas too long.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
Man, you've been playing GTA: San Andreas too long.

Could you please write some material or get some inspiration before wiping your arse on this forum again. It is not a bib for your dribble.
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
quote:
Cinematically, a close tie between Batman Begins, Mr & Mrs Smith and History of Violence.
This is an actual joke right? I mean, I know I haven't written any reviews of my own, but JesusThis is a contender for The Worst Film Ever! and The Most Disappointing Film Ever. It probably wouldn't win either of those, but it would be on the shortlist.

[ 01.12.2005, 09:37: Message edited by: Abby ]
 
Posted by ben (Member # 13) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by kovacs:
Arcade Fire, Funeral

I have ex-forumite "Bailey" to thank for this.

" [Frown] "
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Abby:
Jesus[/i]This is a contender for The Worst Film Ever! and The Most Disappointing Film Ever. It probably wouldn't win either of those, but it would be on the shortlist.

Mr and Mrs Smith is good fun in a light-hearted mega-buster kind of way. I can't really see how it's 'the worst film ever' - it's an extremely efficient action comedy. About the most accurate criticism you can make is that it's all extremely Hollywood, but that hardly makes it a contender for 'Worst Film ever'. The action's really really well delivered, especially the car chase in the people carrier, and most of the jokes hit their mark. There's also a great dig at Grosse Point Blank, when Angelina gets handed the baby at the party and instead of looking at it and suddenly finding meaning in her life, she just holds it at arm's length and sneers in disgust. Also suprising and remarkable is the pasting that John dishes out to Jane at the halfway point. It's a shocking allegory of the bitterness that's built up over the five or six years they've been married, and the frankness of it lends some weight to an otherwise featherlight confection.

As for 'most disappointing film', well that's completely subjective - with no idea what you were expecting, no-one can possibly comment on this. If you were looking for something in the line of March of the Penguins, then yeah, I guess it would be really disappointing. It's a pretty stupid comment, though, because it's less to do with the movie, and more to do with what your own preconceptions. In terms of delivering a slick schlockbuster, the film doesn't really falter.

[ 01.12.2005, 10:18: Message edited by: Thorn Davis ]
 
Posted by H1ppychick (Member # 529) on :
 
lol at Thorn's edit of blockbuster to schlockbuster, but he's totally on the money about the film.
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
I found the action tedious and failed to spot any 'chemistry', the plot had potential and the whole thing had been hyped up, then it failed to deliver anything remotely interesting or unexpected. But I think the main problem was that several people had told me it was ‘better than you expect it to be’ which got my hopes up, then it turned out to be worse than I would have expected it to be, even if nobody had told me it was going to be better! I made it to the end only because we had ordered too much pizza and there was still some left. I don’t like seeing pizza go to waste.

But you have a point. ‘Troy’ would be more likely to win Worst Film Ever.
 
Posted by omikin (Member # 37) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Thorn Davis:
it's an extremely efficient action comedy.

there's nothing like the word "efficient" to make you want to rush out and see a film.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Abby:
‘Troy’ would be more likely to win Worst Film Ever.

I haven't seen Troy yet, but it couldn't possibly compete with The Best Little Whorehouse in Texas, starring Burt Reynolds, Dolly Parton, and Jim Nabors. It was the only film I've walked out on in my life.

[ 01.12.2005, 10:32: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by herbs (Member # 101) on :
 
B-but that was gr9! It featured a pair of pants fastened with velcro, ripped off his nethers with gusto by Burt, and Dolly's vastly superior version of I Will Always Love You.

Heathen.
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
Don't do it Ralph. It is bad, real bad. And long....so long. You get that angry frustrated I want that part of my life back! feeling afterwards.
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
I’ve not really watched many films, or read many books or bought many albums this year, so I’ll be brief on those.

Album

Much as it pains me to ever agree with BR, the bestest album I bought this year was Demon Days. It’s one of the very few CDs on my shelf which I can listen to from start to finish without feeling compelled to skip tracks. Whether or not I’ll still want to in 5 years time remains to be seen, but it’s enjoyable enough.

Book

Best things I’ve read this year are the Initial D manga books, which have brought great joy to my heart. I doubt anyone else here would be remotely interested in them though so I’ll say no more.

Film

Only counting films which were released in 2005, the best I’ve seen this year would have to be Land of the Dead. I know it wasn’t amazing, but it entertained me, and anything featuring zombie hordes is ok in my book, even if I was pretty disappointed with Romero.

DVD

As with the Initial D books, I don’t suppose anyone’s going to be too interested in this but the best DVD I bought this year would have to the Drift King’s Drift Bible. It’s basically an explanation of drifting techniques, and is very well produced and informative. It’s right up my street, and probably miles wide of anyone else’s.

Computer Game

There can be only one really. I had been waiting for it to be released for 3 years, but in a way I think I had been waiting for this game for my whole life. Gran Turismo 4 is not only my game of the year, it’s my game of the decade. It could even become the defining game of all time as far as I’m concerned. It’s everything I ever wanted it to be and more. There’s almost nothing I can criticise with this game. Aside from the inexplicable exclusion of a few notable cars (this is mostly due to politics) and a slight difference in the driving dynamics from GT3 which makes it slightly harder to control the cars using the techniques I had previously mastered, the game is utterly perfect. The graphics are beautiful, with scenery and car models all recreated with studious attention to detail. There’s a sense, at every step, that this game was created as an outlet of the passion Kazunori Yamuichi feels for driving. I suppose to many this could be just another driving game, but to me it’s much, much more.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
I saw a film this year which I hated so much I had to go for a run afterwards to burn off the anger. At half eleven at night.

It was I'll Sleep When I'm Dead 'starring' Clive Owen, an actor who never fails to make me want to eat my own head.

I don't 'get' Clive Owen. He just sucks the life out of every scene I've ever seen him in. I turned King Arthur off half way through, not even Ray Winstone could survive acting along with that plank.
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Abby:
It is bad, real bad. And long....so long. You get that angry frustrated I want that part of my life back! feeling afterwards.

I had that exact feeling after watching Titanic. Was Troy that bad?
 
Posted by MiscellaneousFiles (Member # 60) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
I don't 'get' Clive Owen. He just sucks the life out of every scene I've ever seen him in.

Oh come on... he was good in Eastenders.
 -
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
Troy was good! People just didn't like it because at no point was it obvious who you were supposed to be rooting for, and that confused them. Among the highlights are Sean Bean doing a very good Odysseus, Brian Cox chewing the scenery, Orlando Bloom's miserable performance in his duel, Peter O'Toole begging for his son, and the fantastic face-off between Achilles and Hector. Actully, Eric Bana should be in that list of highlights too.

Also, it's way better than Gladiator - by not having an indestructible hero it actually manages to introduce tension into the proceedings, making the duels a lot more exciting. Plus - it's actually got a really good script which does a nice job of rationalising the role of the Gods and making a few digs at modern American foreign policy, and arrogance. Particularly nice is justifying an attack on the Greeks through dodgy military intel, just because it's what they want to do. It's actually quite dense when you start to drill down into it, and i do think this is largely down to having David Benioff write the script.

The film's beautifully shot, too. I know that's a given with this kind of film these days, but things like the nighht-time firestorm, and the early morning attack look really wonderful. Furthermore, the film does a good job in the bigger battles - like the fear of the Murmadon's (sp?) shields making their way up the beach, or the twin walls of meat bunching against each other outside the walls of Troy.

It's true some of the dialogue is a bit clumsy, and it does feel over-long, although that's largely due to the fact that the film's central conflict is resolved about half an hour before the end.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
I liked Troy. I think it will suffer a reverse-Gladiator effect where, as years go by, people will begin to like it more and more.

The fight between Brad Pitt and the Hulk was cool.
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
I think it was actually worse than Titanic, but bear in mind that when I saw The Big T I was but a child, and perhaps more susceptible to these things. Troy is utterly utterly dreadful, and not in an amusing way (see Van helsing). It is astonishingly tedious and there is no enjoyment as the (many) minutes tick…slowly….past….
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Thorn Davis:
Troy was good!

quote:
Originally posted by Abby:
I think it was actually worse than Titanic

quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
I liked Troy. The fight between Brad Pitt and the Hulk was cool.

I don't know what to do. I have so little free time in my life at the moment, I'd hate to waste it on a film worse than Titanic. But Pitt battling the Hulk sounds cool, sort of like when he wrestled the bear at the end of Legends of the Fall. What to do, what to do.

[ 01.12.2005, 10:54: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
Thorn is usually right about films. If I'm ever in any doubt, I'll get a second opinion from Benway. Often I'll consult with them after seeing a film before deciding whether or not I actually enjoyed it. Thorn was wrong once, but I can't remember what film he was wrong about. It was a dark day in TMO history.
 
Posted by Endemic (Member # 821) on :
 
Troy is big and pretty and and epic and impressing almost totally about Brad Pitt's thighs.


Sorry, Troy fetishises male beauty in a way that is interesting to see coming from a Hollywood usually more obsessed with the female.
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ringo:
Thorn is usually right about films. If I'm ever in any doubt, I'll get a second opinion from Benway. Often I'll consult with them after seeing a film before deciding whether or not I actually enjoyed it.

This is an eminently sensible approach, and more TMOers should adopt this if they wish to avoid making fools of themselves by expressing incorrect opinions on film.
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
Yeah, like that time when I thought I liked 28 Days Later, but then discovered that I actually found it pretty mediocre. That could have been embarassing. Thanks Thornway, you really helped me out there.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
Another film that I didn't like was Broken Flowers. I never thought a film with Bill Murray in it could be so dull. Even Mad Dog and Glory was better than this.
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
I dunno, recently I have had my doubts about Thorn's tast in films...
 
Posted by Endemic (Member # 821) on :
 
Surely and list of contenders for Worst Film of the Year has to include the parlous attempt to remake Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy and self-indulgent overlong tosh The Aviator (relieved only by DiCaprio's naked bum)?
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
Am I the only person here who saw Revolver?
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
I voted it a 10 on imdb, just to be perverse, but I haven't actually seen it.

I could never make a stab at worst film ever. I've seen so many dreadful films, like The Foreigner and Boa vs Python. I think Van Helsing is still the film that upset me the most, though.
 
Posted by dang65 (Member # 102) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Endemic:
Surely and list of contenders for Worst Film of the Year has to include the parlous attempt to remake Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy...

I read a book about Douglas Adams recently. Did you know it took them about thirty years to make that film, off and on? One might expect them to have come up with at least one funny bit in all that time. [Mad]
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
Thorn what did I think of Aliens Vs Predator? I've got a feeling I might think it's one of the worst films I've ever seen, on a par with Underworld, but I'd like to make sure.
 
Posted by scrawny (Member # 113) on :
 
Thorn's review of 'Van Helsing' was one of the best pieces of movie criticism I've ever read. Bits of it still make me laugh now.

He is, however, wrong about Troy.
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
War Of The Worlds was a bit shit. There were some good moments - The train of death, the attack on the ferry - but Spielberg just can't help himself. The way the son survived at the end. The way his in-laws just stand on the porch at the end, looking at him as though he's late for Sunday lunch and better have a good excuse.

I read an interview where Spielberg and Cruise were banging on about how the Cruise character wasn't a hero in this, he was an ordinary Joe trying to survive.

What, like that bit when Cruise takes out a tripod with a handful of grenades? He looked really fucking ordinary then.

I read the HG Wells book in the summer, and the film completely lacked the excitement of that book, that feeling of 'What the fuck...'. League Of X Gentlemen 2 did it so much better.

[ 01.12.2005, 11:44: Message edited by: Roy ]
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Endemic:
Troy is big and pretty and and epic and impressing almost totally about Brad Pitt's thighs.

Sorry, Troy fetishises male beauty in a way that is interesting to see coming from a Hollywood usually more obsessed with the female.

But did you like it? Would you recommend it to someone who maybe gets enough free time each year to see three or four films? I suppose I could go trolling back through old threads looking for Thorn's various film reviews to determine if we're on the same page movie-wise, but I already have a notion of your movie tastes based on your postings on other boards.

[ 01.12.2005, 11:47: Message edited by: ralph ]
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
There's a lot of beards in it, ralph.

 -
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
That sword looks hilariously phallic
 
Posted by ralph (Member # 773) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Roy:
There's a lot of beards in it, ralph.

Thanks Roy. But that's generally not enough for me to enjoy a film. Planet of the Apes contained mostly characters completely covered in hair, yet it did nothing for me.
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
Ralph - I don't think you should bother with Troy. I reckon you'd probably find it a bit heavy going.
 
Posted by dang65 (Member # 102) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ringo:
That sword looks hilariously phallic

He's got his bra on back-to-front as well.
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
I carried out a bit of a poll to see if I am woefully misguided on the subject of Mr & Mrs Smith. I tried not to influence people as to my expectations with the wording, which was...

Please could you give your opinion on the film Mr & Mrs Smith in as many words as you feel necessary...


Here are the answers, all of them with no edits….


I have absolutely no interest in ever watching the film Mr & Mrs Smith.
That is all.
(Cliff)

eye candy. that's about it.
(Amelia)

aint seen it yet.
sorry.
(Andy)

shite
Paul)

It could have been good if it were set in Stalingrad in 1942 and the plot revolved around the Soviet Empire's top sniper and his intellectual yet feisty love interest, who is also pretty handy with a rifle herself.
(Guy)

I want to see it because of Ms Jolie, but the universal awfulness of all the reviews I've read have thus far prevented me from doing so
(Lyssa)

Pointless!
(a random person)

Top chemistry between the two (smoking hot) leads, some decent action sequences and some decent lines but let down by useless, unfeasable plot. The silliness does start to grate after a bit.
Worth a watch if you like pretty people fighting and fucking but don't expect much more.
(James)

pointless, amusing at parts, went on way to long.
(Stuart)

so shite we had to switch it off and do something else...
(Ruth)

Wank.
(Foz)



Pretty conclusive I think. Ralph, don't waste your opportunity on this film!
 
Posted by MiscellaneousFiles (Member # 60) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Abby:
so shite we had to switch it off and do something else...
(Ruth)

Wank.
(Foz)

Are Ruth and Foz together?
 
Posted by jonesy999 (Member # 5) on :
 
I don't think Thorn will fail to notice that three of the people you cite in your pretty conclusive evidence haven't even seen the film in question.
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
Just because you know a lot of plebs, doesn't make you right. Also - Lyssa's comment is an explicit lie, because I was convinced to go and see the film after reading several positive reviews (eg, BBc News, Empire Online), so to say the reviews were 'universally' bad is an outright untruth. Can you email Lyssa and tell her I think she's a fucking lying fucking whore and if I knew who she was, I'd cut out her lying tongue, that fucking bitch. Cheers.
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
Will do...
 
Posted by jonesy999 (Member # 5) on :
 
Can you post her response up here?
 
Posted by ben (Member # 13) on :
 
I'd far rather watch two hours of Abby smacking the shit out of Thorn's weakass taste in films than Pitt and Jolie 'amusingly' pretending to do the same to one another.
 
Posted by Vanilla Online Persona (Member # 301) on :
 
Have Empire Online and the Beeb ever slagged a film when they thought there was a possibility of getting an interview with aforementioned celeb? The last time I watched Jonathon Ross he was busy telling me that the latest Harry Potter was the greatest film ever made. The c.unt. At least Lyssa has stated an opinion which hasn't been paid for. No, she should be killed for spelling a dull name exotically, nothing else, not that any other justification would be necessary.
 
Posted by jonesy999 (Member # 5) on :
 
I'm not allowed to watch anything with Angelina Jolie in it anyway. The fact that she broke up the dullest marriage in show business apparently warrants a total boycott of all her movies...or so I'm told.

I doubt I'll miss much. I can always get the highlights from Robb's Celebdirty Orbs.

[ 01.12.2005, 12:39: Message edited by: jonesy999 ]
 
Posted by ben (Member # 13) on :
 
VOP makes a good point. Check out more credible media (scroll down to the press ratings out of 10) and you see critics either underwhelmed (three 6/10s) positively repulsed (three 4/10s, one 2/10) and only the total fucking nitwits at The Mirror and The Sun remotely impressed.

Thorn - the digital Paul Ross.
 
Posted by Dr. Benway (Member # 20) on :
 
I haven't seen any of these films that you people are talking about. The closest I've come to an authentic summer blockbuster this year is watching half of Spiderman on the television.

And, this business about A History of Violence. (SPOILERS?) Now, I'm quite partial to a bit of Davey C-Burg. I enjoyed that time when Crash was recently shown on the television, and I chuckled my way through "Spider" only a fortnight ago. But, History of Violence didn't move me as much as I was expecting. There, I said it. I liked the characters and the acting and the whole family drama gone skee-wiff, and the yadda yadda, and I even came close to understanding some kind of deeper meaning, but overall, I felt it was missing something. It didn't say anything to me apart from violence is an area of grey morality, and reality can be only be faked for so long, neither of which are super original ideas. Also, it didn't have the 'punch' that I've come to expect from Dave. There was no magic moment.. events just took a linear and predictable course to a finish that you would expect, which isn't normally what he does, which is WHY I think I've missed something ultra crucial. As I've tried to make explicit on The TMO Online, I'm not very bright when it comes to cinema (hence me providing an excellent counterpoint to thorn's cultural objectivism), so I often fail to grasp the most simple concepts that are being presented to me. Can anybody help me out here?

[ 01.12.2005, 13:09: Message edited by: Dr. Benway ]
 
Posted by kovacs (Member # 28) on :
 
I don't think Troy is even worth debating. If it had come out any year prior to 2000, it would be entirely forgotten by now. The only reason you're still talking about it is because it's clinging to the edge of some people's short-term memory. In fact, I'd entirely forgotten its existence before reading Thorn's post. O yeah... Troy. What was that, did I like it? It's not worth mustering up an opinion on it. Neither good nor bad, like a blah 2-hour train journey with one can of beer whose effects wear off by your destination, reading an alright magazine that you then leave on the seat.
 
Posted by dang65 (Member # 102) on :
 
I'm fairly sure there's a direct connection between expectations of a movie from watching reviews/listening to Thorn and how much you'll actually enjoy the thing when you see it.

When I finally got round to watching...

quote:
It could have been good if it were set in Stalingrad in 1942 and the plot revolved around the Soviet Empire's top sniper and his intellectual yet feisty love interest, who is also pretty handy with a rifle herself.
(Guy)

...Enemy At The Gates, I really enjoyed it, thought it was top notch entertainment, a solid story, and at least made an attempt at being fairly authentic. But I'd read so many terrible reviews by that time that the fact is that it would have had to be absolutely appalling before I'd have thought any worse of it.

The latest Harry Potter I was expecting to be a complete thrill from all the reviews and I couldn't really fail to be disappointed.

This is all stating the bleeding obvious, but I'm sure there must be some sort of tidal ebb and flow thing here where the first reviews say, "YAAAAY!" and then a load of people see it and go, "BOOOO!" and then it comes on telly a couple of years later and a load of other people go, "not that bad, really". And ten years later it's a classic, or the most derided shit ever made. It's terribly confusing for a simple chap like me.

ETA: Does anyone else think it's about time Darryn treated us to a preview facility on this 'ere boards? [Mad]

[ 01.12.2005, 13:23: Message edited by: dang65 ]
 
Posted by Roy (Member # 705) on :
 
What do people think of re-makes?

I saw Charlie and The Chocalate Factory at the weekend, and was left with a real '..and the point was?' feeling. Tim Burton remade Planet of The Apes and Sleepy Hollow. He even remade his own film with Batman Returns.
 
Posted by Dr. Benway (Member # 20) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by dang65:


ETA: Does anyone else think it's about time Darryn treated us to a preview facility on this 'ere boards? [Mad]

 -
 
Posted by Dr. Benway (Member # 20) on :
 
what a waste of time.
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Vanilla Online Persona:
Have Empire Online and the Beeb ever slagged a film when they thought there was a possibility of getting an interview with aforementioned celeb?

True as that may be, it still means that the film wasn't treated to universally bad reviews. Lyssa has still sought to turn TMO into a house of LIES.

And Ben - that Guardian review surely makes similar points to me, even flagging up the same scenes as the highlights and describing it as moderately entertaining. Describing a film as 'efficient' is hardly a rave - as pointed out by your little friend Omikin.
 
Posted by Physic (Member # 195) on :
 
quote:
I want to see it because of Ms Jolie, but the universal awfulness of all the reviews I've read have thus far prevented me from doing so
[pedant]
What she actually said, apparently, was that the reviews she read were universally awful, no that all reviews in existence were bad, if she only read the Times and Daily Mail ones say, both of which are shown with a crappy 4/10 rating on Ben's link, she was telling the truth.
[/pedant]
 
Posted by Abby (Member # 582) on :
 
Sadly I am going to Sweden in a few hours, but I shall certainly call upon her to defend herself at some point...Though she has enough practice arguing on the internet to remember to slip ‘that I have read’ in there. A true pro.

And Martin says...."It was a fucking embarrassment. I would stab myself in the face if I had made that film"
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
There's only so long I'll defend a film I thought was 'good' but according to rotten tomatoes the positves outweigh the negative. Most of the good and bad reviews totally contradict each other, mind - "the script was good" vs "the script wasn't good" "the chemistry was great" vs "the chemistry wasn't good" but the correct opinion is the one vikram offered when he declared it "enjoyable". Anyone who deviates from this assesment is objectively wrong.
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Dr. Benway:
I'm not very bright when it comes to cinema

This statement is also objectively wrong.
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Thorn Davis:
Game Resident Evil 4

I've just played through the first level of Resident Evil 4 and all I can say is wow
 
Posted by Black Mask (Member # 185) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ringo:
quote:
Originally posted by Thorn Davis:
Game Resident Evil 4

I've just played through the first level of Resident Evil 4 and all I can say is wow
Did you get overwhelmed by the hospitality of the peasants in the quaint little village?
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
They ran to greet me with open arms, so I shot them in their stupid in-bred faces
 
Posted by Thorn Davis (Member # 65) on :
 
quote:
Originally posted by Ringo:
They ran to greet me with open arms, so I shot them in their stupid in-bred faces

Ha! You'll learn your lesson on that one soon enough.
 
Posted by Ringo (Member # 47) on :
 
Thorn I'd like you to do a proper review of Resident Evil 4 if you have time?
 
Posted by Black Mask (Member # 185) on :
 
Wait until you replay it with the infinite rocket launcher... There's nothing quite so satisfying as vapourising a crazy old lady with some heavy ordnance.
 
Posted by jnhoj (Member # 286) on :
 
Film:

I can't actually remember what I was doing pre June this year, I was at unversity, but....bit of a shapeless mass. Seems like aeons ago. I remember watching some films at new year so I'll put one of those in.

Il postino

lovely sad film about a post man. Who wants to write stuff. lovely.

Music:

Pendulum - hold your colour for raw pumping energy and the The National - Alligator for cute and sometimes ferocious songs.

Game:

Still playing advance wars more than anything.

book: salmon rushdie - shalimar the clown lots of cool sentences that i cant remember anymore and a good story.


Avoid: Painkiller. Mindless, utterly mindless and utterly boring with terrible enemies. Serious Sam was boring, but kind of ok. this is just terrible.

George and Arthuer or whatever that chap who was supposed to win the booker prize wrote...borrrring.

Also not getting on with the various ds games i bought, zookeeper, meteos and yoshis all making me wish for quendan dance and phoenix wright, ace attorney. Polariums ok , but its a bit "back of the newspaper" puzzle, not yet broke into the new advance wars, getting all S ranks on the first one first

[ 07.12.2005, 19:19: Message edited by: jnhoj ]
 


copyright TMO y2k+

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.6.1