The money is in the eyes

Welcome to TMO

Home
Talk
Rants
Life
Music
Web
Media
Society
Sex
Announce
Games

How do I get a tag ?

Read the FAQ !



email us
TMO Talk Post New Topic  Post A Reply
my profile login | search | faq | forum home

  next oldest topic   next newest topic
» TMO Talk » Music » Amplifier question (Page 1)

 
This topic is comprised of pages: 2 1  2 
 
Author Topic: Amplifier question
Ringo

 - posted      Profile for Ringo           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
A basic valve amplifier (home stereo component, not a guitar amp) is around the same sort of price as a high end digital amplifier. But which is better?
Posts: 12211  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
It's probably something you'd have to look at on a case by case basis - I don't think you could say for certain. It would also depend on what other components you're using with it, and it can also come down to personal preference. It's probably something you could only decide by listening to each of them yourself. What are the models you're looking at?
Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Here's a long and utterly incomprehensible article about which is 'best'. It has some diagrams. It may be worth learning a couple of paragraphs and then, whichever option you go for, reciting them at anyone who asks you why you didn't go for the other sort. Eventually they'll not and assme you made a wise and informed decision.
Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
Ringo

 - posted      Profile for Ringo           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Nothing specific at the moment. At the moment we're just using a pair of speakers linked to my PC playing songs downloaded from iTunes which is almost passable, but ultimately we're looking at a decent stereo system with some floor standing loudspeakers. I'd like to be able to have my xbox/playstation, etc, all connected to it, as well as a radio, CD deck, and maybe a turntable. Personally I'd probably be happy enough with a decent digital amp, which would surely be the best solution things like the playstation. Plus I'm not convinced I'd really be able to tell the difference with the quality of the speakers we'd be able to afford, and the bitrate of things like iTunes. But Reema seems set on a valve amplifier.
Posts: 12211  |  IP: Logged
Ringo

 - posted      Profile for Ringo           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Isn't that article about music recording though, rather than home playback?
Posts: 12211  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Right - I think valve amp + iTunes is a bit deranged. I can't see how you're going to get any of the benefit there. In fact it's probably the case with any digital music source that a valve amp is going to be a bit limited. Hmm. I suppose it gives you a base from which to build up your stereo system: as you replace other components you'll start to reap the benefits of having a really good centrepiece, but you won't hear the benefits right away.

Personally, I'd be tempted to give all the components a kind of equal weighting in terms of what you spend; what sort of level they're at, but I can see why someone might want to put an awesome heart at the centre of their system, and then gradually build up the other components to match that. I think I'd find it frustrating, though.

The other thing that's worth thinking about is what kind of inputs you get on the back. Would a valve amp have the optical inputs for your Xbox and PS3, and room to spare for the CD, tuner, and itunes? You'd grow to hate the fucking thing if you had to unplug the CD player every time you wanted to play a game.

Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Ringo:
Isn't that article about music recording though, rather than home playback?

Maybe. I didn't understand any of it.
Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
Ringo

 - posted      Profile for Ringo           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
I reckon it's a bit of a placebo thing to most people to be honest. She asserts that she used to have a valve amp* which was connected to her ex's PS3 (presumably with a ridiculously overpriced set of phono leads) and that the sound quality was absolutely amazing. But like you say, I can't see how the quality from a digital input could be improved over the quality of the sound source. What I think she means is that it had quite a warm, bright sound to it and it didn't suffer from hiss or distortion at low volumes. But I'm sure a decent transistor amplifier would be able to give this kind of sound. Especially since they were using some pretty unimpressive speakers. I reckon it all boils down to "I have a swanky valve amp, therefor everything sounds absolutely amazing". Hi-Fi Snobbery.

*If you want further proof that the guy was a total douche, he kept it on the floor with the cover off with the valves on display

Posts: 12211  |  IP: Logged
Cherry In Hove
Channel 39
 - posted      Profile for Cherry In Hove           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
I run my Xbox through a Denon amp that is similar to this one and a pair of B&O speakers and it sounds outstanding.
Posts: 4934  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Ringo:
What I think she means is that it had quite a warm, bright sound to it and it didn't suffer from hiss or distortion at low volumes. But I'm sure a decent transistor amplifier would be able to give this kind of sound.

Yeah... you definitely don't need a valve amp to get a good, punchy sound without distortion. I mean, there's a point at which any separates system sounds awesome. If you're used to a boombox or a mini-system, then your first reaction is bound to be "HOLY FUCK!!", so it'd be interesting to know what her pre douche-bag frame of reference was.

Of course, for all I know Reema's first ever stereo system was an Arcam amp and CD player hooked up to a pair of floorstanding Mission speakers, and therefore when she says the previous set up was amazing, she damn well means it. However, I'm sort of getting the impression that if you spent wisely, and spread the cost across all the components, you'd end up with something that sounded much better than the DoucheBag9000.

Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
I run my xbox through a Yamaha surround amp, and matching speakers - a package that I paid £179 for in Allders in Croydon. It's probably the best value anything that I've ever owned, and every time I turn it on I'm moved and amazed that it sounds so good and cost so little.
Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
mart
Wearing nothing but a smile
 - posted      Profile for mart           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Speakers are where to spend the money, and will make the bigest difference to the aceness of the sound. That's what I was always told, anyway. An average amp with ace speakers will sound better than an ace amp with average speakers.

I don't know anything about digital amps. I didn't even know they existed.

Posts: 7807  |  IP: Logged
Kanye West
TMO Member
 - posted      Profile for Kanye West           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
i have a richer sounds bargain combo of some 'piece of shit' eltax monitor 3's and a rubbish cambridge audio thing. Sounds fine though.
Posts: 3821  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
This whole debate is pointless as Ringo will only be blasting some shitty 'Dance' dross through his speakers, anyway.

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Or 'Techno'.

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Or 'House'.

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
Ringo

 - posted      Profile for Ringo           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
[Mad]
Posts: 12211  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
'House'... ffs

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
New Way Of Decay

 - posted      Profile for New Way Of Decay           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Listen to what Thorn is saying about an arcam amp and mission speakers. It really depends on what sort of system you go for, it's true, the valve amp being last in the chain will certainly give you a very warm and lush sound, but considering they don't come cheap you have to ask what the point is anyway. Considering you'll sit about 2 meters at the most away from it anyway, spending a lot of money on a valve amp seems a bit much really.

--------------------
BUY A TICKET AND WATCH SOME METAL

Posts: 11617  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Valve amps..? Yeah, buy a fucking valve amp! Then when your music is playing you can look at the valve amp, with it's valve, glowing, and you can point at it and say to yourself, "Look. Look, a valve. That's old. A valve on an amplifier. And it's mine." and rub your fucking belly and grin like a stupid fucking idiot.

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Valve amps!

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
Ringo

 - posted      Profile for Ringo           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Yeah, pretty much that
Posts: 12211  |  IP: Logged
New Way Of Decay

 - posted      Profile for New Way Of Decay           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
If the valves are on display, it's the equivalent to a dog getting its lipstick out.

--------------------
BUY A TICKET AND WATCH SOME METAL

Posts: 11617  |  IP: Logged
Darryn.R
TMO Admin
 - posted      Profile for Darryn.R           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Get the one that goes up to 11.

--------------------

my own brother a god dam shit sucking vampire!!! you wait till mum finds out buddy!


Posts: 6961  |  IP: Logged
Octavia
I hate Valentine's Day.
Stupid commercialised crap
 - posted      Profile for Octavia           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
But, you know, pretty.

 -

[ 26.01.2010, 08:19: Message edited by: Octavia ]

Posts: 3340  |  IP: Logged
Kanye West
TMO Member
 - posted      Profile for Kanye West           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
the only acceptable way to live life is inside a blank white cube, with just a toilet and a single tap for dispensing a food / water combination paste.
Posts: 3821  |  IP: Logged
Kanye West
TMO Member
 - posted      Profile for Kanye West           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
anything else is just pampering towards an absurd set of received social aspirations, and should be rejected by anybody who wants to elevate their existence to being beyond that of a dumb, ego-crazed peacock. Why cloud the senses with all these trinkets and pleasures and sensations? They only prevent us from finding out what we really are.

[ 26.01.2010, 08:30: Message edited by: Kanye West ]

Posts: 3821  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Kanye West:
the only acceptable way to live life is inside a blank white cube, with just a toilet and a single tap for dispensing a food / water combination paste.

Oh, dear. Kanye's been brainwashed by marketing, YET AGAIN!

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Is this what her ex had?
Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
Black Mask

 - posted      Profile for Black Mask           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
quote:
Originally posted by Thorn Davis:
Is this what her ex had?

NSFW! Fucksake, Thorn!

--------------------
sweet

Posts: 13919  |  IP: Logged
Doctor Agamemnon When

 - posted      Profile for Doctor Agamemnon When           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
I've had a good listen to both sorts of amps and, to be fair, I can't tell the difference, no matter how hard I try. A good quality amp, whether solid state or thermionic, sounds good - and a crap one sounds crap. I'm sure a professional sound engineer might be able to spot the "inherently more linear" valve output, but I reckon any regular person wouldn't be able to.

Having said that, I love valve amps. I like the technology, and the engineering, that sits behind them. Retro-tech as it may be, it is rather lovely to think of all those liberated electrons floating about in little vaccuum houses. Yeah, if I could afford it, I'd have my lipstick out, for sure.

If someone is making a valve amp, there's a pretty good chance they give a shit. I mean, take a look at this.

I'd love one of those. I think that's gorgeous. Doggy lipstick or not, I want that in my living room, just so I can look at it whilst idly playing with my winky. It does music too? Awesome.

For the same reason, I love high-end turntables, CD Transports with separate DACs and speakers that look like Stradivarius might have made them.

Yes, it's all just engineering masturbation... but I'd be proud to own any of them.

As for running an iPod through a valve amp... well, I suppose one argument might be that you're putting "more linearity" into the chopped digital signal - but FFS, the source is a compressed mathematical file, and I don't think you'll be adding anything to the "music" whatever technology you use.

--------------------
Not poems and rubbish - SCIENCE!
The Wonderful World of Dr. When

Posts: 1055  |  IP: Logged
Octavia
I hate Valentine's Day.
Stupid commercialised crap
 - posted      Profile for Octavia           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
Do those speakers automatically turn you into the kind of cnut who wears a dinner jacket in the middle of the day?
Posts: 3340  |  IP: Logged
Ringo

 - posted      Profile for Ringo           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
You get one free with them
Posts: 12211  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
He hasn't really given much thought to the placement of his listening chair, either. It's quite easy and cheap to put the chair in the optimum place. Seems a waste to spend all that money on the and then listen to your music with one ear jammed up against the left speaker like an amateur spy listening at the wall with a glass.
Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged
Thorn Davis

 - posted      Profile for Thorn Davis           Edit/Delete Post   Reply With Quote 
The other interesting thing about those speakers is that they reduce even the highest-fidelity recording to nothing more than the sound of a scratchy announcement barked across Reading station at 7.45 on a cold November morning.
Posts: 13758  |  IP: Logged


 
This topic is comprised of pages: 2 1  2 
 
Post New Topic  Post A Reply Close Topic   Feature Topic   Move Topic   Delete Topic next oldest topic   next newest topic
 - Printer-friendly view of this topic
Hop To:


Contact Us | The Moon Online

copyright TMO y2k+

Powered by Infopop Corporation
UBB.classic™ 6.6.1